After years of silence, Brand New has made a surprise return to the spotlight, teasing a reunion tour that has stirred a whirlwind of reactions from fans and critics alike. The news, which might have marked a triumphant comeback for the influential alternative rock band, has instead reopened old wounds and sparked heated debate within the music community.
The band initially stepped away from the public eye in 2017 following widespread criticism of frontman Jesse Lacey’s past behavior, which included public apologies and tour cancellations. That chapter left many assuming Brand New would quietly fade out of the scene for good.
However, recent promotional materials and tour listings have hinted at something bigger brewing behind the scenes. Those suspicions were confirmed when the band announced their official return to the stage—much to the surprise of longtime fans.
But the timing couldn’t be more complicated. Alongside the tour announcement, online communities began circulating renewed conversations about Lacey’s past. Although no formal statements have been issued by the band regarding these resurfaced concerns, the reaction has been swift. Some fans welcomed the band’s return, citing their impact on the emo and alternative rock scenes, while others expressed disappointment, questioning whether a comeback is appropriate without a more transparent reckoning.
This has led to a broader discussion on how—or if—artists with controversial pasts can re-enter the spotlight. The announcement has reignited debates about accountability in the music industry, with many asking: Can you separate the art from the artist? And more importantly, should you?
As of now, Brand New remains silent on the matter. Whether this reunion tour will proceed as planned—or face a backlash too strong to ignore—remains to be seen.
